Ivory painted-brick home with an oak entry door, bluestone steps and black-framed bay windows beside autumn planting.

East Orange's New Brick Church ShopRite Is Still on Its Interim Schedule

In late April, Village Super Market's Perry Blatt told Mayor Ted R. Green's Town Talk audience that the new ShopRite at Brick Church would be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week. TAPinto East Orange reported that promise alongside his prediction that it would be "the best ShopRite that's ever been built."

The ShopRite store locator lists different hours for the East Orange store: 6 a.m. to midnight, Sunday through Saturday. That is the temporary schedule the store opened with in May. With the store heading into its first Thanksgiving, the reason for those hours matters more than the hours themselves. Village tied the return of the overnight shift to finishing the remaining site work, and it tied the new parking lot and the formal celebration to tearing down the old building next door.

What Village Said Would Follow the Opening

The new store at The Crossings at Brick Church Station began welcoming customers on May 27, 2026. It replaced the 55,000-square-foot ShopRite next door, a 67-year-old store that closed for the last time on May 26. The new building has 80,000 square feet, about 45 percent more floor space than the store it replaced. The staff is growing too. The 187 associates from the old store moved over, and Village expects to employ well over 250 people once the store is fully staffed.

Even so, the opening in May was only the first step. In spring interviews with TAPinto and NJBIZ, Village Super Market described the plan for the rest of the site:

  1. Tear down the old store and turn its footprint into a surface parking lot, with Blatt describing a larger lot expected later in the year.
  2. Hold the formal ribbon cutting and grand-opening celebration once the old store was gone and the lot was finished. Marketing director Amanda Fischer said it would include "sampling, promotions and specials."
  3. Return to the 24-hour schedule once all remaining site work was finished.

In June, the company told NJBIZ, "When all remaining site work is finished, we will also return to our 24-hour store schedule at the new location. In the meantime, the new store is operating with temporary hours of 6 a.m. to midnight." The same article said the grand opening was planned for "later this summer." The store's posted hours are still the temporary ones. The overnight schedule that set this store apart from the one it replaced has not returned to the store's own listing.

Holiday Shopping on the Interim Schedule

This is the first holiday season in the new building, and the practical details differ from what was promised before it opened. Here is how the spring plan compares with what the store and the garage list now:

Described before opening Listed now
Store hours 24 hours a day, seven days a week 6 a.m. to midnight, daily
Customer parking Free two hours in the garage, with surface lots to follow Free two hours in the Brick Church Station garage
Address 533 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. 533 Main St Suite 1 on ShopRite's locator
Phone 973-674-1500

A few things follow from that table for a Thanksgiving shop:

  • Late shopping stops at midnight. On the posted schedule, the doors close at midnight and reopen at 6 a.m. The old 24-hour habit of a 2 a.m. run for a forgotten ingredient does not fit these hours. ShopRite's store locator is the place to check for holiday changes.
  • Plan around the garage. Village told NJBIZ that ShopRite customers get two hours of free parking in the on-site garage. The Brick Church Station garage is covered and well lit, with 24/7 access and on-site security, according to The Crossings. Two hours covers a large holiday order. It is tighter if the trip also includes a stop elsewhere at The Crossings.
  • Use the right address for directions. Village Super Market and NJBIZ give the address as 533 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. ShopRite's locator and the garage page use 533 Main Street. For drivers, the garage address on Main Street is the more useful one to enter.

A Prepared-Food Counter With No Seating

The biggest change from the old store is how much of the floor goes to food that is already cooked. The new store has a large sushi bar, a soup bar, hot sandwiches, fried chicken, ribs, grab-and-go meals, cut fruit, a bakery with fresh bread, meat cutters and fishmongers, and a full produce department. It also has a fish fry station that Village developed specifically for the East Orange store. Coffee is $1.99 all day. The store also carries more organic produce and more vegetarian and vegan options.

Fischer described the change to TAPinto this way:

"One of the really big things that's new is all the hundreds of items that you can take home for dinner, lunch or breakfast that you didn't have to cook."

"Take home" is the right description. When viewers on Town Talk asked about it, Fischer said the store would not have food-court seating. Everything is meant to leave the building, so the prepared foods work as a holiday side dish, an office platter, or dinner on a night spent cooking for Thursday. They are not set up for sitting down to eat on site. The ShopRite app also lets shoppers filter products by diet, including gluten-free, vegan, vegetarian, low sodium and no added sugar, which helps when planning a table for guests with different needs.

The company behind the counter is local. Blatt said Village began in 1937 as a fruit stand in South Orange called Village Market, started by his grandfather Perry and great-uncle Nick. Today Village is a member of the Keasbey-based Wakefern Food Corp. co-op and operates 30 ShopRite supermarkets in four states.

The Lineup Around the Store

The ShopRite is the anchor of a larger retail plan. Dunkin' and Rita's Italian Ice were already operating at The Crossings when the developer posted its April 17 leasing update. That same update announced six new leases totaling nearly 75,000 square feet:

  • Burlington, 48,900 square feet
  • Five Below, 9,600 square feet
  • Newark Community Health Center, 4,500 square feet
  • Angel Nails, 3,400 square feet
  • Rainbow, 6,400 square feet
  • Verizon, 1,424 square feet

The sizes show the plan. Burlington alone takes more than half the new leased space, roughly 60 percent of the ShopRite's floor area. Together, a discount department store, a variety retailer, a health center and a phone store make The Crossings a place for several errands in one trip. That is also why the two-hour parking limit will come up more often as the lineup fills in. The April update also listed two restaurant and food-service endcaps, one of 1,650 square feet and one of 4,000, as still available. A sit-down meal is the one thing the ShopRite's no-seating counter cannot offer, and those two spaces are where one could go.

The Walk to the Train Is the Next Phase

The parking work around the old store is the near-term change. The larger change to how the site connects to the rest of downtown comes later. The developer describes The Crossings as a multi-phase, transit-oriented project with 820 mixed-income residences, more than 200,000 square feet of grocery-anchored retail and a 1,200-space garage. Phase 2 is planned to add 420 apartments, 111,000 square feet of additional retail, and a public plaza and promenade linking Brick Church Station to Main Street. In August, the City of East Orange described Phase 1B as a planned nine-story mixed-use building with 420 residential units and several retail spaces, and held contractor-opportunity and workforce events tied to it.

For now, the link between the store and the trains is the garage. The Crossings advertises the garage as being next to Brick Church Station, about a 25-minute express ride from New York Penn Station. Once the promenade is built, a grocery run, a commute home and a walk to Main Street could share one route.

If you live near Brick Church, the site's progress has a direct effect on your block, from what fills those restaurant endcaps to how Phase 2 changes the walk to Main Street. The Arrived Team follows The Crossings closely as it moves through each phase, and we are glad to talk through what each step means for property around the station. Work With Us.

Your Search, Elevated

Backed by market expertise and a sharp eye for exceptional properties, we make the process seamless — so you can focus on what comes next.

Follow Me on Instagram